Is it possible to have a fancy donut glut?
Providence is a small town, but somehow we have TWO establishments that create things like a Passion Fruit glazed donut, or Maple Bacon, or Peanut Butter and Jelly. These doughnuts are slightly larger than average, fluffy, sticky and gooey. They are also $3.50 each and up. That means that even a half dozen is going to cost you +$20.00.
PVDonuts was first on the scene and caused a commotion from the start. LONG lines form every morning at 8:30am or earlier and people wait in the winter cold for a chance to purchase crazy donuts at crazy prices. They sell out pretty much every single day.
Now Knead Donuts has opened in the Downtown area. A small, bright, clean space is their home in what will be a sort of Boutique building, modeled after the successful conversion of a former brothel into the Dean Hotel (the same group of designers/investors are involved in the building). Knead is their first street level tenant.
Knead. Get it? Like Need?
Knead has less of a line, so it has that going for it. On a Wednesday morning I was in and out in no time. The place, as I have said, is nice and clean and neat, with lots of white tile everywhere. The donuts all looked pretty good, but I was dismayed that they only offered drip or ice coffee. I was going to drop about $4 on a donut, so I wanted a fancier coffee or espresso-based drink to go along with it.
The donut I got was Brown Butter and Toffee. Toffee is my favorite thing ever, and on a donut I can think of very few other things that I would rather have. I’ve had PVDonuts before as well, and I can say that this donut from Knead — flavor-wise, texture-wise — was on par. The springy, fluffy, brioche-style innards are very light and yet the donut itself is heavy. It is not as large as the brioche donuts from PVDonuts, but it is the same price or maybe a little bit more.
The crumbled topping of toffee bits was nice and a little messy in a good way. The glaze was sort of maple-flavored, brown butter and toffee all mixed together, and had a nice sweetness to it that wasn’t over the top.
The coffee… was just coffee. I love coffee and drink it black, and I can’t say that this was in any way exceptional. It was good, better than serviceable, but next time I think I will skip the coffee, especially if it adds $2.75 to the price tag (I’m guessing here, as I paid in cash and did not get a receipt. Prices were not listed anywhere, either).
And this all brings me to the takeaway. I am a New Englander at heart, which means, I am cheap. I like Allie’s Donuts and the (former) Donut Bazar and even Dunkin Donuts will do in a pinch if I have a craving. I don’t think I need $3.00+ donuts, as delicious as they might be.
One donut and one coffee cost me $6.78
That’s a decent lunch at most places, that’s easily a far better coffee and a bagel with cream cheese at White Electric (or two of their donuts from Supreme Donuts out of MA if you get there early).
I’m sorry, but because of the high ticket price at Knead, and the long lines at PVDonuts, I might just wait it out with any one of the old school donut shops in the area and see if this fancy, expensive donut trend dies down a little bit.
Old School, non-fancy Donuts
Allie’s Donuts, North Kingston RI
Ma’s Donuts and More, Middletown RI
Donut Bazar, Cranston RI (Retired!)
Sip N Dip, RI and MA
Donut Xpress, Woonsocket RI
And stay tuned for the RI Food Fights #BestDonutRI competition.